Revealing the Cycling and Degradation Mechanism of Bi-Metallates as Anode Materials fro Na-ion Batteries

Na-ion batteries (NIBs) represent an emerging alternative to modern Li-ion batteries. To improve the overall performance of NIBs it is crucial to develop new types of anode materials with high capacity and long cycle life. Among the anode candidates, materials operating under combined conversion and alloying mechanisms (CAMs) are considered as promising. They are capable of delivering high capacity, however, despite theoretical predictions the cycling stability is still below expectations. Therefore, a comprehensive understanding of the cycling and degradation mechanisms of CAMs is crucial to improve their performance. However, these materials undergo multiple chemical transformations, which often involves formation of amorphous and nanocrystalline phases during cycling. Such chemical complexity substantially impedes their full characterization and understanding. Bismuth metallates, with a general formula of Bi-TM-O (TM = transition metal), is a group of ternary CAMs. Their general cycling mechanism consists of an irreversible conversion reaction, which leads to formation of Bi nanoparticles embedded in a Na-TM-O matrix during the first sodiation. This is followed by a reversible two-step alloying reaction leading to formation of Na3Bi with NaBi as an intermediate phase. In this work, we have used operando X-ray diffraction over the course of ∼30 cycles to study the cycling and degradation mechanisms of two CAMs - Bi2MoO6 and BiFeO3. With the help of ex situ X-ray absorption spectroscopy and pair distribution function (PDF) analysis, we have revealed new insights into these materials in addition to confirming the general cycling mechanism. Both materials form the cubic phase of Na3Bi (c-Na3Bi) in the sodiated state with some noticeable differences. While, the hexagonal Na3Bi (h-Na3Bi) phase starts to form after 10 cycles in Bi2MoO6, a combination of c-Na3Bi and h-Na3Bi can be observed after the first cycle in BiFeO3. The formation of c-Na3Bi is kinetically favorable in these systems, while h-Na3Bi is the more thermodynamically stable and, therefore, forms later in the cycling process. Both materials shows three distinct regions of capacity degradation, where the first is initiated by a growth in the crystallite sizes of Bi-particles. This is followed by a disappearance of the Bi-phase as the second step. The last degradation phase is related to the disappearance of the NaBi-phase and locking the system in the sodiated state. The present talk will discuss the mechanisms of these degradation steps in view of the future development of CAMs in greater details.