Revealing the (de)sodiation mechanisms of Bi-metallates through operando X-ray characterisation

Na-ion batteries is entering the battery market as an alternative to Li-ion batteries. To improve their overall performance it is crucial to develop new types of anode materials with high capacity and long cycle life. Materials combing conversion and alloying mechanisms (CAMs) are promising anodes with their high capacity, but obtaining good cycling stability is still challenging. A comprehensive understanding of the cycling and degradation mechanism of these materials is crucial to improve their performance. Bi-metallates, with a general formula of Bi−TM−O (TM = transition metal) is a group of ternary CAMs. Their general cycling mechanism consists of an irreversible conversion reaction forming nanoparticles of Bi-metal embedded in a Na-TM-O matrix during the first sodiation, followed by a reversible two-step alloying reaction forming Na3Bi with NaBi as an intermediate phase. In this work, we have used operando X-ray diffraction (XRD), pair distribution function (PDF) analysis and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) to investigate the desodiation mechanisms of Bi2MoO6 and BiFeO3. Through this work, we discovered that Bi2MoO6 forms the cubic version of Na3Bi (c-Na3Bi) while BiFeO3 forms hexagonal Na3Bi (h-Na3Bi) in addition to c-Na3Bi during the first sodiation. In the desodiated state, the Bi-particles are partially oxidised, while still maintaining the Bi-metal structure, indicating that it is only the Bi atoms at the interface between the Bi nanoparticles and the Na−TM−O matrix that is oxidised. During cycling the NaxBi particles grow larger thus increasing the distance between them and increasing the impedance in the material. This is considered to be the main driver for the capacity degradation that was observed during the first 20 cycles. The operando XAS data also revealed that Mo6+ in Bi2MoO6 does not change oxidation state during cycling, but changes coordination between tetrahedral and distorted octahedral coordination during cycling. The cycling and degradation mechanisms of Bi2MoO6 is summarised in Figure 1.